Religion isn’t usually where people go looking for comedy. It’s treated carefully, reverently, and oftentimes cautiously… as if satire might unravel something meant to hold.

And yet, some of the most enduring faith-adjacent stories make room for humor. Acclaimed author and theologian C.S. Lewis did in his book The Screwtape Letters. Instead of writing directly about temptation, he flipped the perspective, letting a senior demon coach his apprentice in subtly pulling a human soul off course. The result is unsettling, but sharp in a way that lingers.

That approach points to a larger idea within Christian thought: evil, rooted in pride, depends on being taken seriously. But the Christian story also insists evil is not ultimate. It can wound, distort, and deceive, but it does not get the final word.

Which is why satire can be more than a joke. At its best, it doesn’t make light of darkness. It strips away the false weight darkness tries to carry.

This week, we’re exploring what happens when storytelling leans into that tension — using satire not as a shortcut, but as a way to get closer to what’s real

A dark comedy that's fully aware of the line it's walking, Four Lions uses satire to expose how fragile extremist thinking can be. It's uncomfortable by design, showing how conviction without clarity can spiral quickly. The film isn't for everyone (and it's worth noting the language throughout), but that tension is part of what makes it work. Once those ideas are fully in view, they start to feel smaller than they once did.

WHERE TO WATCH →

On the surface, it’s one of Disney’s most offbeat comedies. Underneath, the film is a sharp takedown of pride, ego, and the illusion of control. Kuzco’s fall is played for laughs, but it exposes how quickly power can turn hollow when built on self-interest. In its own way, it echoes the same idea: what looks imposing rarely holds up once it’s seen clearly.

WHERE TO WATCH →

When The Screwtape Letters was first published, it didn't read like a typical theological work. It read like correspondence from hell.

C.S. Lewis wasn't just experimenting with perspective. By letting evil speak for itself, he exposed how ordinary and self-assured it can sound. In the book, the story's main character (Screwtape) isn't loud or chaotic. He's measured, petty, and confident in ways that feel uncomfortably familiar. The closer you look, the less impressive he becomes.

That idea connects to something older. As Lewis notes in the epigraphs of The Screwtape Letters, the Protestant reformer Martin Luther and St. Thomas More pointed to the same tension: evil, rooted in pride, depends on being taken seriously. It begins to lose its grip when it's met with a kind of scorn it can't control.

It's where the idea of "laughing at Lucifer" starts to take shape, not as irreverence or dismissal, but as a refusal to let fear give evil more weight than it deserves. In Christianity, evil may be real, but it’s not ultimate. That's also what satire can do at its best.

Kyle Mann, editor-in-chief of The Babylon Bee, describes satire as taking people's beliefs to their logical conclusion, not to tear everything down, but to expose where things quietly break.

That line matters, especially when faith is involved. Satire can drift into cynicism if it loses its target, flattening everything, including the truths it set out to explore. But when it holds its ground, it exposes distortion without turning truth into a joke, revealing hypocrisy without dismissing belief itself.

And maybe that's the opportunity: not just to comment on culture, but to engage with it differently, using humor with intention and exploring faith from an angle people don't expect.

The results are in! 67% of you voted for Let it go in last week’s poll: When it comes to your past, what’s hardest to do?

A feature film adaptation of The Screwtape Letters is in early development, with the Fellowship for Performing Arts (FPA) partnering with The C. S. Lewis Company to bring it to the big screen.

It’s the kind of project that doesn’t come around often. One that leans into satire without losing its footing, exploring faith through inversion instead of stepping around it. That’s not easy to do, and it’s part of why this stands out.

FPA has spent years building an audience for this work on stage, showing there’s a real appetite for stories like this when they’re handled with care. Now they’re taking the next step.

The film is still in its early stages, and the team has begun inviting supporters to help move it forward. If you’d like to be part of that, you can learn more below.

_{*Plumb News is not affiliated with the Fellowship for Performing Arts or The C.S. Lewis Company and does not receive compensation for featuring it. We’re just highlighting it because we believe projects like this deserve support.}

"He who sits in the heavens laughs; the Lord holds them in derision." – Psalm 2:4 (ESV)

There's a kind of laughter that doesn't come from dismissing something, but from seeing it clearly.

Psalm 2 doesn't suggest that God is unsettled by what's happening below. It shows Him seated, unshaken by the noise of Satan's rebellion. What looks imposing from the ground is not treated the same way from Heaven.

That doesn't make evil harmless, but it does put it in its place. It reminds us that arrogance has limits, and that every power set against God is operating on borrowed time.

That kind of perspective changes the way we respond. We can take evil seriously without letting it become the largest thing in the room, and resist what is false without becoming consumed by it.

Because clarity doesn’t always arrive the same way. It can look like conviction. It can feel like courage. Or, it can sound like a laugh that refuses to mistake pride for power.

Until next time,

THE PLUMB NEWS TEAM